Blog

Relationship Building with Donors Beyond Giving Day

Meta: Higher ed giving is up, but alumni donor counts are falling. Five ideas for relationship building with donors beyond Giving Days, from Homecoming to reunions.
Jenn Goddu
November 18, 2026
#
 min read

Donors remain supportive of higher education with a 2026 report estimating total voluntary support at $78.8 billion, a 4% increase from the prior year. That’s good news for institutions navigating economic and social challenges alongside a widely reported demographic cliff that may see traditional-age undergraduate enrollment numbers falter. Yet anyone in fundraising will tell you they’re always seeking new ideas and fresh ways to build relationships with donors. 

Why is Donor Relationship Building So Critical? 

Consider some of the findings in CASE’s annual Insights on Voluntary Support of Education: 

  • Roughly 60% of institutions reported growth in funds received comparing 2024 to 2025. 
  • The majority (81%) of all donations were earmarked for specific purposes (e.g., student success, financial aid, and research).
  • For the fourth consecutive year, while dollars were up, the number of alumni donors and philanthropic gifts by foundations declined. 
  • “U.S. higher education is increasingly reliant on a concentrated group of older donors, while participation among early- and mid-career alumni continues to weaken.”
  • “Median donor growth was limited to alumni who graduated more than 50 years ago.”

In fact, with 89% of funds received coming from just 2% of donors in fiscal year 2025, the report concluded, “institutions are increasingly relying on a narrower, higher-capacity donor base to sustain their philanthropic revenues.” 

While this might be working right now, it’s not a viable long-term strategy. That’s why fundraising teams — whether they’re representing athletics, alumni relations, academic departments, capital improvement campaigns, or cultural programming on campus — need to always be looking for new ways to engage with their audiences.  

Going Beyond Giving Days

Giving Days, and the annual December GivingTuesday, are a great opportunity to connect fundraising and community-building. Where the focus was once almost exclusively on alumni giving back, institutions are increasingly turning to the entire community to grow the donor pipeline and boost participation and total dollars raised.

A quarter (25.5%) of institutions raise 11-25% of their donations through their Giving Day campaigns, according to a study by CASE and Almabase. Another 11.8% raise 26-50% of their annual goal through matching, leaderboard gamification, on-campus events, and time-based challenges (like Power Hours).

Still, the focus is on a single campaign, often supported by a microsite, social media campaigns, and personal videos from faculty, current students, and alumni. It’s also important to support ongoing fundraising efforts by building a culture that supports community and encourages the engagement that leads to lasting relationships. Try these ideas.

Idea #1: Prioritize Retention

New donor acquisition is expensive. Engagement opportunities that keep someone invested in the community can be a powerful way to encourage long-term relationships. 

For example, one Homecoming at The Ohio State University (OSU) invited visitors to participate in scavenger hunts to find some of the many statues on campus depicting the Brutus Buckeye mascot. Guests to the Columbus campus could download a pass (no app download needed) to demonstrate they’d found one of the over 30 life-sized statues of the anthropomorphized buckeye nut by either checking in or answering a quiz question. Participants were entered to win Ohio State-branded Yeti tumblers.

The guest who comes back for Homecoming and has fun is more likely to stay connected and give again (whether they win the tumbler or not!).

Idea #2: Build Your List

Donor fatigue often stems from request frequency overload. “Americans report feeling overwhelmed after an average of four donation requests in a month,” according to Zeffy's 2025 survey of 1,000 respondents. Often the issue is that the donor list is too small. So, the same people get requests over and again. 

You might look at Family Weekend as an opportunity to connect with an often under-cultivated donor pool. These campus visitors often encounter a student who has many other scheduled events that don’t involve their family. So, create a pass for that student’s school of study. 

While their student is otherwise occupied, the family follows a day in the life of their student in a visit to classrooms, the library, labs, the gym, and dining hall. A mobile pass can help you identify who engages while on campus and build your donor lists even without a direct donation ask on this trip.

Idea #3: Bundle Activities

Traveling to a new city, you often get offered passes that bundle museums and other attractions for one discounted price. Bandwango built its expertise developing these types of one-day, three-day and annual attraction passes for a variety of destination marketers. Now, we leverage that same technology to enable schools to sell paid savings passes that bundle admissions or offer discounts. 

An offering that enables guests to visit campus art museums and attend theatrical productions, music performances, and guest lectures can support fundraising for the performing arts and cultural programming.

Idea #4: Cross-Promote with Community

Homecoming already brings alumni, families, and fans to town. A pass can send them past the stadium and into the local businesses.

For its 2025 Homecoming, Bowling Green State University partnered with Downtown Bowling Green on a free digital Homecoming Passport for alumni, families, students and community members. Passholders earned points toward BGSU-themed gear by checking in at Homecoming events and at 30 participating downtown businesses, which offered exclusive deals and discounts. The passport also put event information, maps and rewards in one place, and no app download was needed.

The effort was led by BGSU’s assistant vice president for alumni engagement and annual giving, which shows how closely community goodwill and giving are linked. Within the pass, schools can also choose to show advertising, either to promote a giving campaign or, when sold to an off-campus sponsor, to earn revenue for the department.

Idea #5: Try a Sponsored Challenge

Sponsored check-ins could provide another way to monetize campus visits. At reunion, for example, guests could be invited to download a pass that counts each of their check-ins at activities or attractions towards their graduation year totals. To trigger fundraising, you might:

  • Line up a donor, board member, or local business to pledge a set amount per check-in (e.g., “Every check-in on this pass unlocks $10 for the scholarship fund, up to $25,000.”)
  • Have a leaderboard for check-ins and use the donor, board member, or local business pledge to give a donation to a fund on the class year’s behalf.

A benefit here is that the participant checking in doesn’t have to give anything. They’re simply showing up and engaging with the platform to help their class donate. Of course, you can also program a milestone so that a certain number of check-ins (say five events) triggers a giving page link. (e.g., “You’ve visited 5 spots on campus. Make a gift in honor of your favorite one.”)

Fundraising Gets a Boost with Bandwango

Many future donors are on campus right now. CASE’s data shows that participation among early- and mid-career alumni keeps weakening, so the work of building those relationships can’t wait until graduation.

At the University of Nevada, Reno, a pass welcoming incoming students and encouraging them to explore the city saw power users visit 20+ locations in their first month on campus. Students who build ties to their school and its community from the start are the young alumni a school will one day ask to give back.

Instead of relying on a single campaign to spike donations, mobile passes encourage the whole community to engage year-round, from a student’s first week to their 25th reunion. With Bandwango, private and public institutions can create digital experiences that encourage exploration, collect valuable first-party data, and keep students, alumni and families engaged on and off campus. 

When you’re connecting town and gown, Bandwango handles merchant outreach, so your fundraising team can stay focused on strategy.

Find out more from our higher education team. Book a demo.

‍

Previous 
Blog
Next 
Blog
No previous 
Blog
No next 
Blog